Re: Situation: Was I right or wrong..what would you have done?
Posted 4/8/2008 4:29:23 PM by Shelly

Here's the way I see it- as a parent of a toddler.

If a parent yells at a child or tries to discpline them in a way that others feel is excessive, they get comments, looks and someone may even call CPS. Almost any form of physical discpline in this day and age is forbidden and may even be grounds for a complaint to the state board.

And as someone who has recently started doing time out with a 2 year old, if I do it in public (which I have), she will scream bloody murder worse than when she falls and actually hurts herself. So you don't want to know the looks I get when she is having one of her tanturms and I am discplining her or ignoring her tantrum. I actually had another parent come up to my child to see if she was OK when threw a tantrum and I was ignoring it because I wouldn't let her have a pacifier in the playground. I was not 3 feet away from her.

If a parent doesn't do enough, people complain that children have no discpline and the parent needs to get more involved.

So really, since everyone's idea of what a parent SHOULD be doing is different, a parent really can't win.

And maybe its different for me because i live in Manhattan and don't have that "village" of community members. My village is my friends and families. And of course, they can say something to my daughter (who isn't even 2 yet). But I know I would be livid if some stranger without authority (like someone from the church, school, etc...) came up to my child.
Print Post      Close Window