Hot Water Heater Options - Tank or Tankless ???
Posted 12/13/2005 5:57:32 PM by DjPiLL

Some of you may remember the thread I started a month or two ago here .

Long story short... we are in the house now. We have no separate hot water storage tank in the house.

We can take a shower... and I guess the water is "hot enough". But I come from the city where I am used to HOT HOT water (I am talking 140 degrees and up) Chat Icon This is somewhat of a culture shock for me now being in my first house.

We are going to start to explore the option of a supplemental hot water heater. We have two options that I can think of.


Hot water heater tank: Would need to be installed in a separate area from my furnace (some piping would need to be run... maybe 10feet or so). I have the space available.... but I heard electric for these tanks can kill you since its on all the time (whether you are running water or not).

or

Tankless water heater: This is a new technology that I did a search on this website and nobody seems to talk about. Here is a link to one I am talking about. This device will heat your water on-demand... meaning it will only run when you run your hot water. This will use a lot less electric. The size of it will also allow me to install this right next to my furnace which will keep the piping needed to a minimum. This will also run endlessly if needed... and I would theoretically never run out of hot water since there is no tank to empty.


I have 100A breakers in my house... and installing either option would probably mean I would have to upgrade my electric first. I know the tankless heater has some hefty electrical requirements to run (when its on). Does anyone here have a hot water tank of at least 30gal and have 100A electric?

Both options would probably cost the same to install (around $1500 or so).


I am leaning towards giving the tankless solution a shot since it seems more practical. But I don't know a single person that has this in their house... I don't want to be a "guinea pig". Chat Icon


Any opinions on this?

Thanks.

Print Post      Close Window