Re: WAR IN IRAQ
Posted 3/28/2008 6:05:34 PM by JessInCA
Posted by Kara
Posted by wannabemom
the soldiers should come home....
Basically, factions in our own gov't lied about classified info and skewed its interpretation.... presented it to congress, and rode the wave of 9/11 as an excuse to move the troops from the afghan/pakistani boarder to Iraq. It was all hideously wrong.
I have tremendous empathy for the troops.... especially since the stop loss order. They are also being neglected once they return home by the VA.... it's all so morally wrong.
I politely disagree with the notion that while we entered into Iraq for reasons that may not have been clear or correct, we must finish what we started becuase we invested so much in this situation. Just becuase we've been in there for several years and so many soldiers have sacrificed so much does NOT oblige an equal amount of additional soldiers to do likewise.
Iraqs government is less unified than the US gov't circa 1855. a religious civil war is not only imminent, it is already occurring, and is basically unstoppable.
I dislike the fact that our gov't is funding one religious faction against the other... This is not WW2... there is no obvious right or wrong. we should just step back, and let the civil war take its course w/o our contributions. After all, neither side has US interests at heart, and giving aid to one side over the other will only complicate things for us down the line....
This isn't an issue of just letting civil war take its course. This is a problem of leaving a weak country with a nascent government and no real military power unprotected in a volitle, yet extremely important, region of the globe. If we just up and leave the Iraqis to fend for themselves, it won't just be a civil war -- it will open Iraq up to invasions from neighboring countries and other world powers. The stability of that region is vital right now, whether we like it or not. Leaving Iraq to fight for itself could lead to far worse than the war that is going on now. It has very valuable natural resources and very aggressive neighbors. There are other aggressive countries that would love to step in and get a foothold in that region, too.
It's not about JUST the Iraqi people. Secure borders there are pretty important for the international community. Whatever people thing about why we started the war, etc., etc., we simply can't just up and leave at this point. It would be disastrous -- and would have far-reaching effects beyond even the Middle East.
I agree that it's time to develop a practical, WORKABLE withdrawal plan... but we need to understand that withdrawing from Iraq will be a process of YEARS, not days and months as many politicians want us to believe. Like it or not, we are there, and to me, it's less a matter of 'finishing what we started' and more a matter of maintaining stability in the region - and the world.
And on a completely different note - prayers for all our soldiers, all over the world.
|