Re: John White Sentence
Posted 3/21/2008 2:10:15 PM by Goobster


Posted by Ophelia
you have other children...you know what it's like to need help in a situation and have the police do NOTHING...you don't want to hurt anyone...you just want them to leave your daughter alone and GO AWAY...and you have a gun...something to protect you while you try to get these "boys" off your lawn....

you are telling me that you would just sit on your tuffet and let them break in...if they tried to...

OH HELL NO.

I would be right in Mr. White's chair for sure. even the electric chair, if that is what I FELT it took to protect my family...and I felt it was the only way.



Well you story has one huge flaw.

NO ONE Was trying to break into his home so he was NOT in imminent danger. And that is where he went wrong, so very wrong.

And that is also my point about being a ticking time bomb. Just b/c of your "past history" with one incident, one cop, you hold all others accountable and decide to take matters into your own hands? And your past history should be the problem of the current people you believe to be threatening you? Is it quite possible that you might be overreacting, based on fear and emotions of the past?

If the world worked like this, if we all did this (disregard authority and take matters into our own hands) we would all be at risk everyday based on the pasts of others.

Our past does play a role, but that is exactly why cases like this are critical. Others should not have to pay for the brunt of what we faced in another senario, and if they do, they should be held accountable accordingly.

ETA- And in your senario, you should hopefully have the sense that if you take matters into your own hands, your children may have to live their lives with their mother in jail for "taking mattesrs" into her own hands when she is not a law enforcement official. And you would HOPEFULLY have the sense to make that RATIONAL decision (one that John White apparently didn't have and for that he should be held accountable for longer than 2-4 yrs).
Print Post      Close Window