Re: John White Sentence
Posted 3/21/2008 12:46:34 PM by Bxgell2


Posted by Goobster


Posted by Bxgell2


Posted by Goobster


Posted by greeneyes361708


The point is, he was given a sentence fitting the crime IMO. It was a tragic accident. John White didn't intend to kill anyone that night and unfortunately, it happened. He didn't deserve 20 years in jail. He made a bad judgement call. I don't think he's a real danger to society.



If he didn't intend to use the weapon or kill anyone, why even have loaded weapons (in more than one location in his home)?



That's not enough to show intent, at least, not under the law. If you take that argument, then presumably every single person in the US who has a loaded weapon in their home may be accused of intent to kill before anything even happens.

We, as a Country, deemed the right to bear arms a necessary component of our Constitution. We cannot contradict that by assuming an intent to kill with every purchase.



I understand what you are saying, the concept of the law. But if I had a loaded gun, I know it would certainly be b/c I INTENDED to use it when I saw the need to protect myself.



Intending to use a gun at some point in your life and intending to actually murder someone are two different things.
Print Post      Close Window