Re: John White Sentence
Posted 3/20/2008 3:17:43 PM by TheWhiteRabbit
Posted by Ophelia
actually, I believe that they were still ON his property, albeit at the foot of it.
the thing is this.
did he commit a crime: YES. he was convicted of acting recklessly, which it was proven he was.
it was NOT proven that he went out their with the INTENT TO KILL anyone. so it is NOT murder. NOT murder. under the letter of the law. and believe me, if you were in the situation, you'd want the letter of the law on your side too. (and I believe he did yell to his wife to call the police...not sure if she did or not..)
should he have gone outside with his gun???? maybe...maybe not. perhaps he would not have been charged at all if his gun had been licensed...would that make you all feel better?
by all accounts this was a standup guy, looking out for the safety and well being of his family when confronted at HIS HOME by a group of young MEN that wanted to "kill" his son. that called him and his son "N****R" and other racial epithets.
that apparently weren't even scared by the presence of the gun...so who knows what would have happened had the gun NOT gone off....who knows what those drunken young men would have done to that family.
it is terrible and it is tragic. but it is NOT murder. and his sentence is IMO fitting under the circumstances and under the law.
I agree 100%. Again we can all say 'he should have done this' 'he should have done that' but if it was YOUR CHILD being threatened by a mob of drunk kids, you may have reacted the same way. I do not believe he INTENDED to kill that boy, and obviously the sentencing says the same thing.
|