Re: AI Question
Posted 3/19/2008 5:40:18 PM by heidla
Posted by Goldi0218
I said this last night and I'll say it again...
The Beatles have an incredible catalog of music that will stand the test of time. BUT, IMO, they are known for song writing skills and musical composition moreso than amazing vocals.
I think it was up to the contestants to stretch themselves as well as create arrangements of songs that were never meant to be re-interpreted. I cannot think of ONE Beatles song in which any one of them had outstanding vocals. If that was the case, how can it be expected that these semi-novices would?
JMO.
Paul McCartney actually has a great voice IMO. I agree that John was not much of a singer.
JMO, but it is harder to sing and sustain a simple melodic line then it is to sing a ton of runs and scream a few notes.
|