Re: AMERICAN IDOL 3/18
Posted 3/18/2008 9:30:20 PM by TaraHutch


Posted by sunflowerjesss

Simon....I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU!!!

Should not have done this "genre" two weeks in a row!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I have been agreeing with Simon non-stop tonight. I love the Beatles more than ANYTHING...literally. Last week I gave them a pass...this week - DISASTER. You really shouldn't go wrong with their songs- they're GREAT songs and they have gazillions to choose from.

The problem here- song choice. Michael Johns should never have done Day in the Life. WHYYY didn't he choose the Joe Cocker version of "With a Little Help from my Friends"?

And yes, I agree with Simon- Carly was totally indulgent. DH thought it was great- but he didn't know the song. If you love the original, you'd probably realize how completely ridiculous and inappropriate her interpretation was.

Poor Brooke- she should have sung Blackbird instead.

I can't believe so far I liked Amanda the best!Chat Icon At least she was fun! David Cook was good but the talk box was ridiculous.

Sorry for the long post- I just logged on.

Oh geez, whyyyyy would you sing Yesterday?!?!?!Chat Icon

This episode is bringing the total Beatles/music snob out of me!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window