Re: AMERICAN IDOL 3/18
Posted 3/18/2008 9:18:27 PM by FelAndJon


Posted by Goldi0218


Posted by FelAndJon

I don't understand what Simon said about Carly? Indulgent?



My guess is that he felt the song is an incredible song and by her singing it, she put herself out there as a winner and she is not there yet.





Posted by lbelle821


Posted by FelAndJon

I don't understand what Simon said about Carly? Indulgent?



he says that a lot. Basically he is saying that sometimes they pick songs because they KNOW that they can belt them out and not necessarily because they are challenging or show a different style. At least that is always how I interpret it.



Thank you both for explaining! I felt like an idiot listening to him! Chat Icon Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window