Re: would this be appropriate??? (kinda long)
Posted 3/13/2008 1:54:12 PM by Kara

To be more specific and hopefully more helfpful than my first post on this thread, I just wanted to point out some specifics of your proposed email that will work against you, not for you.

First, always ask for references in person or over the phone. Period.

Second, it is not appropriate to tell the potential reference what you want them to focus on or not focus on. I cannot think of too many people who would agree to give a professional reference and then give a bad one. If they cannot give a good reference, they will decline the give the reference at all.

Third, you have to ASK for a reference, not say "I will need you to give me a recommendation." Quite frankly, they don't NEED to give you anything. A good recommendation is a professional favor and you should never tell someone they must do this for you. Unless they just cannot give you a good recommendation, I am sure they will be more than willing to agree to be used as a reference.

Fourth, you're asking a supervisor, albeit soon to be former supervisor, to do you a favor. I don't believe it is appropriate to ask for that favor in a group email. If you want someone to take time out of their schedule to provide you with a good reference when potential employers come, you owe it to that person to make an effort to ask in person or over the phone. An email to multiple recipients isn't the right way to do it.

Finally, why even bring up the fact that someone might think you lack skills in a certain area? You were let go because they didn't have a position for you in the fall. If you don't believe that, I'm sorry -- but operate under the assumption that they are telling you the truth. If they are telling the truth (and they probably are), they are likely more than willing to give you a good recommendation. I wouldn't even think for a minute to assume they feel you are less than competent for the position. Give yourself more credit! Chat Icon

Good luck. Trust me, you want to ask in person. If you ask in person (and just ask -- no extraneous information required!), I bet they will say yes. If you send this email, however, I fear one or more will be tempted to say no.
Print Post      Close Window