Re: Morality spinoff
Posted 3/12/2008 4:38:32 PM by wannabemom


Posted by Bxgell2


Posted by KPtoys

No... I think morality is what YOU think is right and wrong not what some politician has deemed right and wrong.



But oftentimes, those two are aligned, no? I mean, there are, at least I think, certain givens of humanity - you don't steal, you don't kill, you don't abuse, you don't eat other people, etc. Those givens have become over time, an essential part of our laws.



to give the clicheed example from a an undergrad philosophy/ethics class:

a family member is desperately ill.... if they were to take a bottle of a very expensive medication, they would recover completely. the family cannot afford the pills, and there is no way to get them legally for free. should you steal them from the pharmacy?

after much discussion within the class, the answer approved by the class as being the most moral is 'yes'. to let a person die a preventable death is more amoral than to steal a bottle and accept the consequences.

This situaion is also often used in psych classes to discuss emotional development as it relates to ethics. children will usually say 'it is wrong to steal... ALWAYS'. Only adults would see the nuances of the argument and realize that ethics and the law occassionally will conflict.
Print Post      Close Window