Re: Did I miss something
Posted 3/12/2008 8:42:35 AM by headoverheels


Posted by GoldenRod


Posted by Diana1215

I believe that the Relationship board was made private in case it got too offensive - to not steer advertisers away from the site - or maybe new members. I don't really think the main reason for making it private - was for posters privacy. KWIM?

Anyway - I have said it before - I am all for that extra layer of protection. Yes, people can easily make up a screen name and sign in - but then doesn't Ron have the IP address? That person is not completely anonomous anymore.

I don't see why any parent wouldn't at least like the board to be private? That's the part that I'm not getting. Everyone is in such an uproar over this - but really - I think it would do nothing but benefit us (moms and dads)

I am not going to stop posting pictures of my son on here if it's not private - but like I said the extra layer of protection would be nice.

And, I also think that people should use their judgement when posting pics. Again, JMO.




It's been touched on in several posts, but if Parenting is made private, there won't be many new people joining. I know that I wouldn't have joined if I couldn't see what was going on first. I'm not giving out email info and other details just to find out that there's nobody in the site, and they are just gathering email addresses to spam you. Advertisers would pull out, since the don't have a wide audience anymore. That would force Ron to charge. Many people would leave if they were forced to pay. Making this private would surely lead to this site being shut down eventually, or at least being a shell of its former glory.

All that would be accomplished by making it "private" would be to hurt legitimate users who want info and support from us. The people we are concerned about will get around anything, and actually have an easier time getting info if it's "private". Then, people would *feel* safer, and post more info, which would still be exposed to anyone who wanted that info.

In reality, even if Ron has the IP address, it won't always do much good. It is very easy to fake your IP address, or go to a free Wi-Fi location (Starbucks, McDonalds, etc), or steal from your neighbor's house.

I think making it private will just make legitimate users *more* vulnerable and exposed to the people we are trying to protect ourselves from.



i have to agree with this... i personally feel comfortable posting some pics, although i don't know how i will feel once Chat Icon arrives, but if a member doesn't feel comfortable because the board is not private, there is always the option to not post pics at all.

i think a lot of us forget that we joined b/c of the TTC board, or the pregnancy board, or Home, or Pets... and then transitioned to the other boards, so it's easy for us to say we would have joined anyway. what about the moms who joined after their DC were born - and we just looking for parenting advice? would they have done so if the board was private?
Print Post      Close Window