Re: What would you have done?
Posted 3/7/2008 3:59:04 PM by Goobster


Posted by MrsPJB2007


Posted by CathyB

I wouldn't have done anything. Who knows what the back story is. Sounds like she was at the end of her rope. I know I've had days where I've lost my temper and snapped at my dd and she started to cry. And then I felt even worse. If that had happened in public and someone approached me I would probably have freaked out on them.




ditto

i know people might say "i have to intervene in the best interest of the child" but in reality some people don't know the entire store of their situation.

unless i watched a mother seriously BEATING their child and causing obvious harm to them that is a extreme--i would not intervene



ITA

It would depend on how hard. I can't tell how hard just from your description, nor can I tell other things from your description. I would have had to see it for myself.

I had gotten many a smack when I was a child and I lived to tell about it. I am not saying I would do it, I don't have kids yet but I won't judge (unless of course I saw and felt it was out of line). My gut instinct says the mom acted childish (playing tit for tat with the slapping), but was it blatant abuse? I would not say yes to that from what you wrote.

JMO
Print Post      Close Window