Re: Idol 2/27
Posted 2/27/2008 10:23:23 PM by Jax430

My input, after watching late again, and not reading any of your comments:

Carly: Good, very talented, but I didn't LOVE it.

Syesha: EH..I was bored.

Brooke: Jewel anyone? Nice song choice for her. I like her.

Ramiele: I really like her. Not as great as last week, but still good. She has a lot of personality.

Kristy Lee Cook (I don't know why I feel the name to use her whole name): I would have preferred someone else singing this song. It wasn't bad, but I just don't like her very much. She bores me. She was better this week then last week, but I still find her bland.

Amanda: love this song, didn't like her doing it at all. Just bad. I really think she's a one trick pony.

Alaina: Eh...not a good song choice, IMO. I like the song in the context of Grease, but it's a boring song for a performance.

Alexandrea: what an odd outfit! nice vocal, but a boring song.

Kady: ugh...boring, bad song choice, no personality.

Asia'h: she really struggled with this song at the beginning. I thought she'd do better with it, but she pulled through it. It ***** that she was sick. I think she has a lot of potential.


Overall, my favorites were Brooke, Ramiele and Carly, but I wasn't overly impressed tonight.
Print Post      Close Window