Re: American Idol Predictions
Posted 2/27/2008 1:23:36 PM by DRMom
Posted by 04bride
Posted by melbalalala
Posted by SweetTooth
Just curious, those who don't like David archuletta, what don't you like about him? I don't see how you can deny the kid has an incredible voice.
I'll repeat some of what I said on a previous thread. Two big reasons I think he is WAY overhyped:
1. His voice is average. A little throaty and breathy for a 16 year old boy. Very good at hitting notes, but I wouldn't sit and listen to a record of his and think ahhhh brilliant.
2. I am sooo sick of his "wow, really?" "Oh, wow, Gosh!" "Oh! no it IS a competition" and the goofy smile that accompanies this. I believe that this kid has a mom that has wanted her son to be a star since day 1. Put him on Star Search, and groomed him from the day Season 1 started for AI. She told him "act humble, sweet, and cute, and you'll be a shoo-in".
He is the equivalent of a pageant girl that grows up and learns how to be likeable by judges and the public, but deep down is really kind of annoying.
i agree with all you said
I disagree but its all opinion based anyway. Although I am a singer and have been judged at NYSSMA and also taken voice lessons. So I "may" be a bit more qualified
I find it funny how they keep hyping this as the best group ever and most of them stink! They could narrow it down to 4 or 5 contestants right now and stop wasting all our time. I also think they should increase the age limit as, obviously their ideas of what makes an American Idol far differs from what the voters think..for example Ruben, Taylor, etc.
The show seems to think if you've got a nice azz people will vote for you when I think it is actually vocal ability that wins in the end
|