Re: Giving birth naturally.. no epi, no meds... no ANYTHING.
Posted 2/26/2008 8:41:40 PM by sfp0701
Posted by wannabemom
Posted by Dragonfly75
Posted by sfp0701
Posted by wannabemom
well, it was more than just sanitary conditions.... many women died becuase they either bled to death, or the labor was so long and difficult that the baby's head swelled (due to bruising), and got stuck in the birth canal.
I just bring this up becuase sometimes, you do need meds to get the contractions stronger, or you do legitiamtely need a cessarian.
IMO I think a proper balance must be struck between the use of meds and procedures when it is necessary, and the acceptance that birth is a natural process that frequently can proceed with minimal intervention....
I don't think that anyone here was saying that they would NEVER use meds or get a c-section if thier babies lives or thier lives are in danger. I think they prefer to go no meds and if an EMERGENCY should arise medical intervention would be allowed. I don't think anyone here would let thier baby die or let themselves bleed to death just to avoid meds or a c-section. That is a little insulting. Maybe I interpreting what you said wrong?
ITA. Although I don't think the OP was trying to be rude. I feel like there is this false argument set-up against natural childbirth that assumes that natural childbirth means the refusal of life-saving interventions when needed -- that's certainly not the case.
I think most natural childbirthers are highly educated on the process and willing to accept any interventions that are legitimately needed -- they just understand that when unnecessary interventions are introduced it can be harmful to them or the baby -- that's what they are trying to avoid.
For the record, I was replying to the other posters comments stating that unsanitary conditions were the prime reason for things going wrong way back when.... the first paragraph of my post did not have to do with modern natural childbirth at all. Of course there are contigency plans for modern natural childbirth that include procedures and meds if things take a turn for the worse. I didn't intend for anyone to read my comments and think I was implying that moms would refuse procedures out of principle.
The intention of my posts was actually reasonably pro-natural childbirth.... I do think many procedures and meds are used when they occassionally are not yet truly needed.... and there seems to be some medical stats out there that shows that to be true... I was also attempting to be democratic and also mention the other side of the coin, where drugs/ procedures are actually genuinely necessary.... (my 2nd paragraph...)
I find this thread to be similar to a thread on religion.... it's way to easy to offend people unintentionally by merely stating a personal opinion.
hope that clears up my statements
Thanks for clearing that up. I didn't think that was what you meant but I wasn't sure. Thanks though.
|