Re: How well do you take constructive criticism?
Posted 1/4/2008 11:18:59 AM by Lanabean
Posted by rojerono
My reaction to ANY criticism is almost always going to be initially defensive. But with some time and reflection I will either calm down and absorb the advice OR resent the person giving it.
The things that will determine which way I will go are as follows:
The actual criticism: Was this given out of love or affection? Was it given to help me in some way? Or was it offered to hurt, injure or show superiority? Was the criticism given with suggestions for solutions and in context to a specific issue or issues? Or was it just thrown out there randomly>
The source of the criticism: Who gave it to me and do they have the background to offer this advice? If you are going to critique my parenting skills - but have no children - I am going to doubt your expertise. If you are going to give me advice on keeping my house clean - but you live in a filthy place - I am going to have a challenge taking you seriously. Also - if you are just a flat out negative person who always seems to look for the bad in everyone and everything - I am going to take what you say with less than a grain of salt.
The validity of the criticism: I know if something is true. I might not want to admit if I have a flaw when you call me out on it - I mean I am HUMAN - but if it is true it will resonate on some level. I will contemplate it and I will be forced to correct or ignore. If it is not true - I will be upset and will question your motives. I mean - if someone criticizes my food choices and I am sitting their with a plate of fries and a greasy burger, the evidence speaks for itself! But if I am working hard on my diet and making healthy choices day after day and someone starts telling me that I eat too much junk food - I am going to balk.
More than you asked for, right?
not at all...these are great points and insightful. I don't feel like I'm ever the one OFFERING the criticism and sometimes I don't know where people come of! Advice is one thing, and I do offer it to friends/family...sometimes unsolicited, but always because I care.
|