Re: Children of Divorce
Posted 12/9/2007 11:54:24 AM by pharmcat2000

First, Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Second, I would just like to say that this is one of the most snobby, judgemental, small-minded, ignorant comments I've heard in a long time.

I can tell you, when I was in my early 20s I was dating a guy for 5.5 years. He told me once that his parents cautioned him against marrying me because my parents were divorced. Well, when we eventually broke up, he ended up moving in with somebody 6 weeks later, got her knocked up, got married out of wedlock, and was divorced within a year! I on the other hand, finished grad school, have a very responsible job, am married to a man who treats me perfectly (unlike the ex), and I see myself staying married for the rest of my life. Yes, his parents stayed married, but his mother was so emotionally abused that she should have left. They stayed together, and in turn, he never learned how to properly treat his wife, and his sister ran away when she was 17 after having had an abortion, and dating every guy from the "wrong side of the tracks". So she obviously never learned how to be treated as a woman either.


Posted by nov04libride

Looks like there may be some truth to these generalizations though...From the book "Between Two Worlds". Though I like to think of it as all of us succeeding despite setbacks, in which case it makes all of us even better!


Children of divorce are three times as likely to be expelled from school or
to become pregnant as teenagers as those from intact parents and are five
times as apt to live in poverty.
...
The study compared 750 Generation X adults of divorced parents with 750 who
grew up in intact homes. The differences are stark. Two-thirds of children
of divorce who stay in contact with both parents (and many do not) say they
felt like they grew up in two families, not one, which creates "endless and
often painful complications for a child."
...
Fully 44 percent of children of divorce said "I was alone a lot as a child"
vs. only 14 percent of those in intact families - a three-fold difference.
...
A fifth of young adult children of divorce agree that "I love my mother, but
do not respect her," triple that of those from intact homes. A quarter of
young adults from divorced homes disagree with the assertion, "My father
clearly taught me the difference between right and wrong." That compares
with just 3 percent of those from intact homes. If the study had included
the many children totally abandoned by divorced dads, the ratio would have
been much worse.
...
What are the lessons of "Between Two Worlds?"

First, two-thirds of those who divorce who are in low-conflict marriages,
should work harder to save their marriages, or at least wait until children
are grown before divorcing. Only a third of the divorced said that they and
ex-spouses tried to save the marriage.



As far as some of the results of this study:

As for the higher number who live in poverty, is that as children, or when they grow up? If it is as children, well, sure if there is less money to go around, then there is a chance this might happen, but it doesn't mean the child is destined to be poverty-stricken, or that the parent isn't working to make the situation better.
*****
I can see how children may feel like they are growing up in 2 families rather than 1, and how it might create some internal conflict for them. Although, I think it can work out okay if the parents work at making the children feel comfortable with the situation rather than a child sometimes feeling like he has to "choose" between his parents.
*****
The 44% who said they were alone, did they resent it, or was it just a fact of life that they were stating? Sure, a single parent can't be at work and at home, so the kids are bound to be alone more, but the kids can still grow up okay (as my siblings and I did).
*******
I don't understand the finding of children of divorce saying that they don't respect their mothers. I don't know where that is coming from. As far as the remark about the fathers not teaching them the difference between right and wrong, that may be because the father wasn't around that much, or at all. It may be that it was the mother who taught them these things -- not that the child never learned them. And what is wrong with a mother teaching her children life's lessons?

I really think that when parents divorce, it is not a decision that is made lightly. I think it is a last resort, and as many other posters have said, it may be what is actually best for the children, depending on the situation of the marriage. And, there are some wonderful parents out there who do make divorce work for their children, and we are all examples of successes despite what the "statistics" show. I agree with the PP who said it is "parenting" that determines how a child grows up rather than the outcome of their own marriage.

p/s - sorry for the long answer, this just really got me steaming!!
Print Post      Close Window