Re: The Golden Compass
Posted 12/3/2007 7:02:11 PM by rojerono


Posted by cpanyc


Posted by rojerono
The death of The Authority (again Pullman was clear in his book that this character is NOT God in that he did not create anything) was not really violent.

I promise that my intention is not to sound like a snot, but I think you may want to read the book instead of basing your opinion on someone elses interpretation.


The author himself said his books are about killing God. I have no interest in reading the books or seeing the movie for this reason. I am simply trying to explain why people who believe in God would have a problem with it.



I have a very strong faith in God - so please don't interpret my belief that art and religion can live independently as an atheist view point.

Pullman's commentaries about 'killing God' - when taken in the actual context are about killing a creation of man. He assigns the Authority as a being that people have determined to call God - but who is NOT in fact the creator. In the book souls dissolve and become part of 'the universe' from which them came. This includes the character of The Authority - who is grateful for his release to the universe. This may be construed as a very theistic point of view all in all.

I am not interested in a debate, I just think it is worthwhile to be fully informed when making a decision. Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window