Re: Green Car of the Year
Posted 11/28/2007 1:54:32 AM by HoneyBadger
Posted by Kara
Posted by rojerono
Posted by Whamtastic
Posted by marriedinportjeff
I don't get it..... fine, it has great milage for a honkin' SUV, but it doesn't even get 25 mpg.... and most of its drivers will STILL be driving it the majority of the time either alone, or with one passenger.... If a family has under 3 kids, there usually is no need for an SUV. Most of my friends who are SUV owners are almost always driving it alone, and never are hauling a lot of stuff.
if it were a genuine truck or van, one that electricians or plumbers could use on the job, THEN I might agree.....
not terribly green to me
ITA. Celebrating how "green" an SUV getting 21 mpg is will only keep people thinking it's okay to drive a vehicle like that when they don't need to be. I see tons of SUVs on the road every day and they almost always have one person driving alone without tons of cargo- IMO, there's no need for that and it should not be applauded as green to get 21 mpg, just because it is less terrible mileage than other SUVs.
I agree - and as others have said there are NON Hybrid SUV's that get better mileage.
I get that it is a good idea to give kudo's to a vehicle that would traditionally burn up a lot more gas... but calling it Green Car of the Year is just off to me.
It's kind of like a marathon where a handicapped person comes in last. They definitely should get applause for finishing - but you shouldn't call them the WINNER of the race.
I don't know of any FULL SIZE, V8 SUV's getting better gas mileage than this...
I have a mid-size SUV that gets better gas mileage than this (not a hybrid), but I don't know any full size ones that do.
You won't, there's no such thing as a full size, V8 SUV that gets that kind of mileage.
I know, I drive one.
Alone.
Everyday.
What can I say? I know, I'm the spawn of s*tan. But (for instance) when I go camping with my husband or we go on a road trip, we have NO problem fitting ALL our gear in our full-sized SUV as opposed to our friends who drive Hondas (and the like), including those with small SUVs and still have to ask us to fit their stuff in our vehicle b/c it won't fit in theirs.
I know it's hard to believe, but they do serve a purpose. And just b/c I don't have children doesn't mean I shouldn't own one. What if I owned 2 or 3 large dogs? Do you suppose they would fit in a Civic? I'm gonna guess and say, no. Also, what if I only have 2 kids? Have you ever seen a back seat with 2 carseats in it? Pretty much the rest of the back seat is useless. There's no room for anything else. So if you want to carpool, you pretty much can't b/c you're lacking that 3rd row.
Those are just a few examples.
I just don't understand who generalizations and accusations can be made by someone who doesn't own one of these vehicles... It seems very rash and honestly lacking substance. You can have an opinion, but to state it as if it were fact, just doesn't seem fair to me.
I understand that SUVs aren't for everyone, but owning one doesn't make those who drive them horrible people.
|