Re: Well, all this Santa talk...LONG
Posted 11/22/2007 12:34:06 PM by Reese1106
Posted by prncss
Thanks for responding girls. I think my main issue is that on many levels, it feels completely "right" to be celebrating Christmas the way we do, with no religious connection, because that's what my family does and always has. On the other hand, now that we do have a child, I wonder if having her celebrate Christmas, but with no intentions of ever giving her a religious education as a Catholic, is the right thing to do. For me, yes, it's right because it's tradition, and because at least I was raised Catholic, so there's some sense to it. For her, what sense is there to celebrate holidays that she'll have no religious connection to? See my dilema? As for other religions, I think that the problem is that I have read a lot about various religions and have friends of various backgrounds, and it's hard to find something that I really do believe in. It's like, if I could make my own religion that pieced together the bits and pieces of other religions that appealed to me, then I'd be happy. Does that make sense? Maybe I should just start my own religion Just kidding, just kidding. But seriously, I just have a hard time believing in anything other than what I can really stand behind. It's not like I can say, "Ok, I agree with most of this religion, so I'll just let the other things that I don't agree with go." I truly think that I'm just not meant to have a religion. So I guess I do believe in something, it's more vague than most people. Geez, I'm probably not making sense.
You are completely making sense to me. I've struggled with the same issues personally and even more so now that we have a child. The conclusion we've reached is that, for us, Christmas is a celebration of family and friends. It has never been about the religious aspects for me personally. DH and I do have beliefs but we do not necessarily think we need to raise our son Catholic or Baptist just because that was how we were raised. If you do not celebrate the religious aspects of it for your family, then that is what is right for your family. Again, this is what we have found works for our family. I would not judge anyone based on their own beliefs or try to tell them why they should or should not do something.
|