Re: Well, all this Santa talk...LONG
Posted 11/22/2007 12:19:50 PM by Moehick


Posted by dm24angel


Posted by Moehick


Posted by KateDevine


Posted by dm24angel


Posted by Moehick


Posted by KateDevine


Posted by Moehick

Do you call your celebration Christmas? Why not just call it something else and celebrate family and all the good things you have in your life? I know for me if I was not a catholic I would not bring Kerri to see Santa Claus or participate in all the other "Christmas" things.....but I would take the day to appreciate everything I have and get together with family.



I am NOT flaming you. But I think that is not really realistic. I mean, Santa is not a religious symbol, so why should someone's child who isn't religious not get to enjoy that? I am not catholic and I've always called Christmas Christmas.

I would think Santa is probably the least religious thing about Christmas and is specifically for ALL kids, not just Catholic kids. Chat Icon



Santa Claus is indeed a saint in Christianity....the fact that he is a saint is just dripping with religion

Santa Claus



Its early so maybe I missed something, but I read the whole thing and found no link to Jesus's birth and Saint Nicholas?




Okay...maybe I am missing it as wellChat Icon Yes, he is a Saint, but if we want to get technical, Saint Nicholas Day is December 6th.

Unfortunately, Santa has become somewhat of a commerical symbol for Christmas and I think it would be a little unfair to not let a child enjoy Santa in that manner. He11, I have jewish friends whose kids enjoy Santa in some form or another.



If people who do not celebrate Christmas want to place their child on Santa's lap (who does signify the holiday) then that is their perogitive. I just would not do it.



I think the point was that Santa has nothing to do with the birth of Christ or the Christmas celebration as it relates to christianity.

Its more of a catholic tradition....

But traditions are not always relgious...

Example- Santa at Christmas....

IMO- A jewish child can enjoy Santa b/c he is a catholic saint perhaps but what does he stand for? Gift giving...not anything ultimately Christian ?



If I took a poll on here asking what holiday do you think of when I say Santa Claus I don't think many would say Memorial Day or Hannukah or Thanksgiving. All I am saying is that Santa Claus is a definite representation of Christmas which is a Christian holiday.

ANYONE can enjoy Santa, no matter what religion you are. I never stated they shouldn't....all I said is if I was not Catholic I wouldn't partake.
Print Post      Close Window