Re: Well, all this Santa talk...LONG
Posted 11/21/2007 10:29:06 PM by Bxgell2

Oh trust me, I have many of the same quandries now that I have my own daughter.

I was raised in a fairly religious home - schul three times a week, observed shabbat, went to hebrew school two times a week, the whole nine yards.

BUT, when I was 13, the day after my Bat Mitzvah, my parents sat me down and told me they are atheist Chat Icon but that they wanted to expose me to both the cultural AND religious aspects of judaism and that's why they had me so involved in everything, but at that point, at 13, it was my choice. So, at that point, I decided for myself that, while I wholly accept my heritage and the rich cultural traditions that are so intertwined with judaism, I wholly rejected anything religious.

So, here I am, an atheist, who has a deep, deep understanding, appreciation and love for my culture and tradition, but have no ties whatsoever to the religious aspects of it.

I feel like, with Alex, I'm always skirting that fine line between each extreme. She's in daycare at a conservative synogogue, so I'm worried about her exposure to too much of the religious aspects of judaism - I know deep in my heart she will learn from me and my husband all she needs to know about being a good person, without needing religion.

But, by the same token, I feel like I'm stealing from her an element that was given to me - CHOICE. While I absolutely shower her with tradition and culture, I don't expose her to anything religious, so that, unlike me, when she's 13, she won't have the knowledge, background and information to make that choice for herself. I know this, but I have such an immense distaste for organized religion that I just can't bring myself to celebrate the religion in my home or at synogogue. I'm hoping the amount of exposure she gets in school will be enough.

I think my point is, you have to find a medium that you are comfortable with - for me it's a little easier because judaism, unlike other religions is so intertwined with the culture so it's very easy to absent from the religion while embracing the culture - but maybe you can do some of that for yourself? Don't feel guilty by separating the two and picking and choosing those "traditions" that you grew up with, that you want to pass on to Ava. Celebrating those moments that were passed down to you, doesn't necessarily mean you are embracing the religion. I think much of it really comes down to perspective, if that makes sense?
Print Post      Close Window