Well, all this Santa talk...LONG
Posted 11/21/2007 9:23:14 PM by BaroqueMama

Has me feeling really confused. And please excuse me for using this board to let my feelings out, but it does pertain to Ava on many levels, so I felt this was the best place to do it.
Anyone who knows me knows how completely unreligious I am. I was raised Catholic, but I was asked the leave my church at 13 when I refused to make a poster supporting the church's pro-life campaign. My mother was the president of a women's group at the time and took my sister and I on a march on Washington to support a woman's right to choose, and she spent a long time discussing with us the differences between being pro-choice and pro-life, then let us make our own decision. Anyway, moving more towards the point of this, I was asked to leave the church because I told them that I was pro-choice. The following year, my mother paid a large donation to the church so I could make my confirmation just incase I decided to get married in a church someday. She wanted me to have the choice to be Catholic or not.
Fast forward to my wedding. I wanted desperately to have my wedding ceremony be non-religious, but to appease my grandmother, we decided to get married in the church. After years of not really being Catholic, JT and I decided that when we had Ava, we would finally stop the nonsense and not have her christened because neither of us consider ourselves to be Catholic. I don't ever plan on going to church again, and if asked, I say I do not have a religion. I'm not denying there is a God, I just don't really think about it at all. I wish I did have a religion I believed in and could be a part of, but I don't, and that's ok.
But here comes the part that is driving me nuts. It just doesn't feel right to be celebrating Christmas when I really think about it. I feel like, why am I going nuts over Christmas if I don't even believe in the religion? I know that the way my family celebrates Christmas is more of a celebration of family than anything else, but then, that's not really Christmas, is it? We have zero tie to religion on the holiday. None. Not a single thing that has to do with Jesus. No church, no songs about Jesus, no prayers. Nothing. Yet, I still celebrate it, and I feel like I'm setting Ava up for a lifetime of meaningless, empty "holidays". I feel torn because they're my family's way of celebrating in general, so do I deny her of that, even though my family all celebrates it, or do I continue on the tradition with no connection to religion? I don't know. It just sits heavy on my mind this time of year. As I'm out shopping and wrapping presents, I have to stop and ask myself, what for?
Maybe it doesn't matter what we celebrate. Maybe it's just good enough that we celebrate each other, but after reading some responses to the picture with Santa thread, and the beautiful, heartfelt things that some of the other moms wrote about why they will not be bringing their jewish children for pictures with Santa, it just has me thinking, yet again, of what an empty "holiday" this really is for me. It just really bothers me. And I really needed to get that out. I'm sorry if it was on the wrong board, but thanks for reading if you've gotten this far.
Print Post      Close Window