Would you sacrifice location...
Posted 11/18/2007 7:49:59 PM by SpiceGirl

...for a house that cost less? Here's our scenario...we're looking at houses on the South shore, South of Montauk...mainly in East Islip. Our price range is the low 400's. We found a house we love and even got the seller to accept an offer 70K less than their asking price, BUT the house needs the following work:

New deck
new retaining walls
small addition on the back of the house needs a new roof
Updated Kitchen/bath

Those are the big ticket items. My FIL thinks we should pass on this house because it will cost way too much $$$ for these repairs and take years for us to get all of this done. He'd rather see us buy a house somewhere in Bohemia or Ronkonkoma where we can get a home for around $380K - with no work needed. Leaving more money each year for savings, vacations, etc.

My DH and I are so torn. Financially, it would be SO MUCH easier for us to buy the cheaper house and not have to worry about lots of big repairs. On the other hand, we really love the other neighborhood, even though the first few years will be tough (2 kids in daycare Chat Icon ).

Would you sacrifice location? Or would you buy the house in the neighborhood you love and tighten your purse-strings to make it work?
Print Post      Close Window