Re: How come when researching/talking about "good" towns...
Posted 11/16/2007 2:54:33 PM by SweetTooth


Posted by Rooster


Posted by Beth1210


#35 Jerchio- is the first LI school to make the ranking

Top 1300 public HS in the US




I know that this is off of the topic, but I have a really hard time believing that the way that public high schools are ranked on this survey is accurate in anyway. If you look through the previous years, there is entirely too much discrepancy from year to year. Yes, a school can have some years that are better than others, but these changes are too drastic.

For example, I looked at my district (smithtown)-

2007- 854
2006- 297
2005- didn't make the list of 1300 schools
2003- 264


It's not just Smithtown either, it's similar results with a lot of the schools. When they do college rankings, schools might move up or down a few rungs but it is never this drastic...it takes time for a school to get much better or go south...certainly more than one year.






This is true. And each source that ranks school districts uses different criteria.
There really is no concrete way to rank school districts. I think a lot of what goes on here on LI anyway in terms of saying a school district is "great" or not is very biased.
Print Post      Close Window