Re: Spinoff to Staph Post- Article from NYTimes
Posted 10/25/2007 4:05:35 PM by JessieQ


Posted by Kara


For the ones that only use alcohol as an antibacterial agent, they are killing far fewer germs / bacteria than soap and water. On top of that, as I just recently learned, alcohol won't kill viruses... (Not saying staph is a virus, just throwing it out there). Soap + water is all you need.

Also, I am pretty sure I've seen several "alcohol free" hand sanitizers advertised recently... can't remember where. I'll try to look it up.

And... I believe there IS medical proof and many ongoing studies about the overuse of antibacterial agents (as there is about the overuse of antibiotics)... I was reading an abstract online about a paper that said recent studies and research show that there is strong support for the idea thatthe overuse of antibacterial chemicals aids in the proliferation of atiobiotic-resistant bacteria... I think more studies were recommended and I believe more studies are being done.

I'm by NO means an expert. Just passing on some things I read / heard about. Chat Icon I still say regular old soap and water are the way to go.



I agree, soap and water are the best, but in a pinch I think the alcohol hand-sanitizers are an ok alternative. As I said in the other thread, my worry is antibacterial soaps, because they use antibiotic chemicals like triclosan that could breed resistant strains of bacteria- they actually speed up natural selection in bacteria. Alcohol on the other hand kills almost all bacteria indiscriminantly and doesn't really breed resistant strains, and anyway even if they become resistant to alcohol, it's the resistance to antibiotics we worry about (we're not going to treat a person with a MRSA infection in their organs with alcohol).

My issues with hand sanizers are 1: Purell brand, the most common, is only 62% alcohol, and tests show you need at least 70% alcohol to get the best result, and 2: even though it seems like alcohol may "inactivate" some viruses (according to Wikipedia, I still don't think it's going to protect you from viruses as well as just washing your hands with soap and water would. But if it's the difference between not washing your hands, and using the hand sanitizer, I'd use the hand sanitizer.
Print Post      Close Window