Re: Staph infection its hitting a lot of schools update now Roosevelt
Posted 10/25/2007 2:04:18 PM by JessieQ


Posted by MsMBV


Posted by JessieQ

Having a daughter in day case and relatives that are on high school/college sports teams, yes I'm concerned. But other than washing my hands (and my DD's hands often), trying to limit touching my hands to my eyes/mouth, and cleaning/covering any open cuts/wounds, all of which I should be doing anyway (especially since flu season is coming up), I don't plan on doing much else.

I just also want to add that years of over-use and misuse of antibiotics and the ubiquitous use of antibacterial soaps (as well as other antibacterial products) is at least partially to blame for breeding these "super bugs." I hope this scare will finally convince people that antibiotic soaps are not only not necessary in most cases, but are speeding the evolution/natural selection of bacteria to breed bugs that are resistant to all but the strongest antibiotics.

I agree about the over-use of antibiotics, and I had a very hard time selection a pediatrician who agreed with my philosophy regarding this. But.... I thought that it was recently proven that the antibacterial soaps did not kill more bacteria than regular soap? Chat Icon



Yes, that's the point. Antibacterial soaps are no more effective at reducing bacteria on the hands than regular soap, and since there is evidence that the antibacterial agents in these soaps may help build up a cross-resistance to other antibiotics, they have no positive purpose. Here is a link to a research article summarizing the latest findings on this. Aiello et al., Clin. Inf. Dis., 2007

ETA: I re-read your post, and I just wanted to clarify. Antibacterial soaps don't kill a larger percentage of cells than just soap, but while the soap and water removes the bacteria equally with no preference (as does 70% alcohol or bleach), exposure to antibiotics like triclosan is an outside pressure that, yes, will kill off most bacteria, but some will be able to survive. It's literally natural selection in bacteria- and we're speeding it up. Think about it- if you use antibacterial soap, you're killing off all but let's say 1% of the bactera on your hands. Ok, well 2 hours later that bactera has divided many times, and now if you use the antibacterial soap again an even higher percentage of those bacteria will be resistant to the soap. The next time it'll be an even higher percentage. And so on and so on.
Print Post      Close Window