Re: I really have to ask...
Posted 10/20/2007 9:37:41 AM by Bxgell2
Posted by KellyFG
Posted by steph4777
Posted by KellyFG
I didn't read all of the replies, not even sure if we're still on topic but IMO its not right & I personally feel offended, insulted & like I'm being treated unfairly based on my race(white) when I see these types of things. I truly feel it is discrimination & there is no amount of explaining the history of slavery that will change that for me. I am 3rd or 4th generation american, my ancestors weren't even on this continent when slavery was an active part of life here. Another example is "Black Colleges", still alive & well in this country. I thought we are all "allowed" to go to school together now.
I've been reading this thread for the last two days and decided to stay out of it since I didn't feel I could add anything of real value to the topic. But when I saw this comment I had to respond.
I went to one of those "Black Colleges", which by the way are known as Historically Black Colleges and Universities. They needed to exist in a time when blacks weren't allowed in other universities. These schools were not created to exclude anyone, they were meant to provide quality (and affordable) education to anyone. While they may still be predominantly black, there are people of non-color enrolled.
Sorry Kelly, didn't mean to go off topic but I don't want people to believing that these colleges in any way exclude certain groups.
Thanks for taking the time to explain Steph, I know black colleges do have people of all races allowed. However the "historical" reason for holding on to a name to depicts a painful time of segregation to me is hypocritical. If any school, business or other establishment kept displaying the signs that directed black people away or stated only white people were allowed there would be outrage. If "we" are going to move past the hurt from those times, we ALL need to move past it. IMO
I think there's something that we're missing here - there is a very significant difference between the *purpose* of an historically black college, and business who posted signs directing people of a certain color to stay out. THe business's purpose is clear - blatant discrimination while the other is to help those who are discriminated against. Because of the difference in purpose, I firmly believe that while one SHOULD dissipate, the other should continue to thrive UNTIL all vestiges of continuing discrimination are gone.
It's easy to say that we shouldn't pay for the sins of our ancestors, but the simple truth of the matter is that, while you feel it's unfair, it's just as unfair when you look at the cold hard statistics which show that minorities are STILL paying the price of what our ancestors did, each and everyday. You simply cannot remove the historical context from the world we are living in today.
Eventually, yes, all decisions, all institutions and all groups should have absolutely nothing to do with race, religion, sex or age. But, that simply cannot be until discrimination is completely wiped out of this society. Until then, we *need* mechanisms to uplift and assist those who are still feeling the very palpable effects of what happened in this country 40, 50, 60 years ago.[
|