Re: I really have to ask...
Posted 10/19/2007 2:58:07 PM by Ltdentway99


Posted by Goldi0218

I read as much as I can tolerate without developing vertigo or an ulcer. I came pretty close to both.

First I will address the OP. I think a lot of people would be offended. I think people would start an uproar and I think it would be down before the glue dries. I am not sure how I personally would feel about it.

Now for my ramblings.

There is no question that many groups whether based in culture, religion, race or any combination has had its share of discrimination and/or persecution. One's groups problems should never be measured against another's.

That being said, I can only speak of what I know - the persecution of my ancestors base on religion and culture. Judaism is a religion AND a culture - like it or not - it just is. Many people celebrate Jewish culture without ever setting foot in a temple or Kabbalah center. It is a big part of who I am and what defines me as a person and a woman.

It may be surprising to many people - especially those of us who live in densely populated areas filled with diversity - as to how small national and world-wide Jewry is. Judaism makes up less than .25 percent of all of the religions in the entire world - a total of 13 million people. It makes up about 1 percent of the religion in this country. Why people feel threatened by such small numbers always blows me away.

Surely, it is obvious that Jews were not ever big in numbers, but it is pretty obvious how the Holocaust nearly eradicated who was here and left sadness as well as despair for many. Some were left with no faith and others vowed to overcome the atrocities and teach their children so this could and would never happen again.

As a Jewish child and a Jewish woman, I was always taught it was my duty and responsibility to perpetuate the faith by having Jewish children. A Jewish couple is often told that in order to do this, they must have at least three children - one to replace the mother, one to replace the father and one to keep things going for the future. I know a lot of people will roll their eyes at this one - too bad - it is how I was raised. This is why so many Orthodox families have so many kids - they are fulfilling a promise.

Due to my own reproductive limitations, at this point, I pray that G-d will bless us with at least one healthy child. We plan to raise our children in a Jewish home - they will know their religion and their Jewish culture so they can teach THEIR children.

The fundamentals of all religion (and just plain old human decency) basically preach the same ideals - do unto others.... I work in an area that is racially and religiously divided. As I drive through Crown Heights on my way home through East New York, I see a billboard with the Grand Rebbe Menachem Schneerson (whom Lubavitcher Jews see as the Messiah) and it says "Do Acts of Kindness". It does not say "Do Acts of Kindness to Jews Only." Goodness is goodness no matter whom it comes from and where it goes to. When my father was dying, we had prayer chains going from Pentecostals, Catholics, Muslims and others and we accepted each one graciously - we did not reject any thing because it wasn't based in Judaism. Geez I even carry a prayer of St. Gerard in my bag every day in hopes that some of the prayers and good wishes will help me to conceive and maintain a pregnancy. So what if St. Gerard doesn't go to my shul.

It is no secret that I met my husband on JDate. I have said it many times before and I will make no apologies for it. I do not feel guilty for being proud of it either. I did not seek a Jewish partner because I felt Jews were superior. I did not do it because I felt others were inferior. I did it out of a promise and obligation. Some people do not believe in organized religion. Some people may find my choice to be either racist, separatist or exclusive. I look at it as trying to preserve my religion so it doesnt die out. It is already pretty darn close.

If a person sees the avenue I chose to create my family and fulfill my promise as discriminatory or close minded, too bad. Maybe if my ancestors weren't treated like crap in the first place, this wouldnt be a discussion.



Wow, Goldi- I could have written this myself. Thank you.
Print Post      Close Window