Re: I really have to ask...
Posted 10/17/2007 4:16:30 PM by Ophelia


Posted by Shelly


Posted by Ophelia


Posted by Shelly

Since they are the majority, they will be the majority of the people making up any event. So you don't need to specify because it is assumed and/or understood.

And I think you have a great point. If "white" seems like a dirty word, it is all the white supremicists fault.



Please address this point in the context of the one I made above.

b/c I this is not something that is "understood" for me...or anyone in my mixed breed family, as far as I know.



As YOU said:

Posted by Preguntas
The simple fact is- if the majority of people are actually white Christians, then they are going to be the majority of people making up any event.



If a group is the majority of peope making up an event, you don't need to specify that it is for that group.

When its for a minority, you need to specify that, because if not, people will assume:

Posted by Preguntas
The simple fact is- if the majority of people are actually white Christians, then they are going to be the majority of people making up any event.




I am not Preguntas. I did not make those points.

My question, directly to you, is this...

You say something is "assumed" to be for the majority...but I hold no assumption.

I don't think companies give a rats arse what color or religion you are when it comes to buying things. they may not break bread with you, but I don't think (unless it is target specific...that would not be used by any other group) that they WANT to exclude any group. that is why so many companies DO make commecials with minorities in them.

and even still, the PEOPLE in the commercial/ad may be WHITE, b/c there are MORE white people in the US (though not by much) but that doesn't mean a black person, a chinese person, or a Jew is not WHOLLY INVITED to use the product/partake in the service.

I have to say that I think part of the assumption is the monkey on the back that is memory. we are trained to think white people exclude minorities...white people banding together = trouble... and the whole 9 yards.

So, if YOU, Shelly, hold the assumption that nothing is for Jews unless you are officially invited, then that is on YOu. it doesn't mean that is the intention. but, b/c there are people that think in the same vein as you do, whitedatersonly.com could never exist (I do not argue that it should...I argue at the hypocrisy.)
Print Post      Close Window