Re: DBQ's - HOW DO YOU HELP YOUR STUDENTS WITH THESE?
Posted 10/10/2007 8:12:19 PM by CurlyQ


Posted by donegal419


Posted by CurlyQ

In order to write the essay we use the hamburger.

I have a hamburger organizer that I have drawn:
top bun: opening (restate the question)
ketchup: document #1
cheese: document #2
lettuce: document #3
Patty: document #4
bottom bun: closing (restate the question)

Before I begin, they color their graphic organizer and label it just like how I described to you. I then laminate them and they use them through out the process. We also pretend to eat a hamburger without a "top bun" and how it really doesn't work because you would get very messy. We then talk about this with each part. This helps them understand how it is important to have each part for the DBQ. This is usually my first kick off lesson.

When we are actually going through the practice DBQ's, they actually will write on a blank hamburger to organize their thoughts for the essay. I have also explained that sometimes you may not have to have the "lettuce", you must read the directions to see how much "stuff" should be in your hamburger. Their planning pages are all hamburgers, it is so cute.

I also have them write a seperate paragraph for each document. I teach 5th grade self-contained and although a more elaborate essay would combine documents together, that is too abstract of an idea for my students. They simply aren't at that level yet. In my 4 years of teaching 5th grade self-contained they have all gotten 3's and 4's with giving each document its own paragraph so I don't really worry about it!

I also teach them to start all of the "stuff" paragraphs with this sentence:
Document # __ is a ____________ (photograph, newspaper article, etc.) that shows_________. They then need to write 2-3 more sentences following that tie it to the question that is being asked.


Sorry this is so long winded!



WOW... i love this.... i have 5th grade self-contained too. i've already started preparing them this year as has the speech-language patholigist... but i am notebooking this idea for next year. thanks!



Thanks!!Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window