|
Re: I need your opinions...
Posted 10/26/2005 8:58:11 AM by redstar I have very mixed feelings about IUI's and why they are done so much. It depends on the reasons why you are doing them, whether you should try naturally. Usually if you have male factor issues, the iui's may help. IUI's are unlimited in NY if your insurance covers infertility. It is my theory that in NY the Re clinics push them and never suggest natural cycles because they get paid more for a IUI. IuI's require so little of the RE's time that it's very cost effective. I speak to women internationally on fertility friend, and it's so rare to see them do IUI"s unless they live in NY. I started putting the two things together. I conceived naturally, 'twice". Since I started doing IUI's I haven't conceived at all. I used to think, that IUI's wouldn't hurt and only help the chances, but I am not so sure anymore. I know of a girl who was ttc with IUI using a sperm donor. She was single and chose to be a mother. She was still 'dating' an ex of hers, that she once conceived with yet miscarried. Her "ex" did agree to father her child if she chose to go that route. She tried several times and failed. Her ob/gyn, told her, just go try the old fashioned way, since you conceived that way once. He said obviously the greatest success is that way :) Lo and behold, she got pregnant naturally and has a beautiful son. Tomorrow is cd3 for me and I am going to express my feelings about IUI's with my RE. I am at the same point you are Donna. Not because of the time restraints, because I am on a leave from work due to all the RE visits, but because there is just a part of me that feels IUIs may not be in the best interest for all people. Here is some very interesting information I have found. Ideally an IUI should be performed within 6 hours either side of ovulation — for male factor infertility some doctors believe after ovulation is better, otherwise chances of success are higher with insemination before ovulation with the sperm waiting for the egg. When timing is based on an hCG injection, the IUIs are usually done between 24 and 48 hours later. Typical timing would be to have a single IUI at about 36 hours post-hCG, though some do it at 24 hours, and some clinics are reporting better results when doing the IUI at 40-42 hours post-hCG. If two IUIs are scheduled, they are usually spaced at least 12 hours apart between 24 and 48 hours after the hCG. Some reports show no increase in success rates with two IUIs, but others suggest it may increase success as much as 6 percent. Some doctors will base timing of IUI on a natural LH surge. In that case, a single IUI at 36 hours is the norm, but doing them at 24 hours is also pretty common since ovulation may be a bit earlier. When two inseminations are planned, they are usually timed between 12 and 48 hours after the surge is detected. The egg is only viable for a maximum of 24 hours after it is released.Searching through about a dozen medical journal articles and a number of web sites resulted in a rather wide range of statistics. Basically the odds of success are reported to be just under 6 percent and as high as 26 percent per cycle. The low statistics are with one follicle, while multiple follicles resulted in as high 26 percent success. Another influencing factor is sperm count. Higher sperm counts increase the odds of success; however, there was little difference between success with good-average counts and those with high counts. The overall success rate seems to be between 15-20 percent per cycle, judging from the articles which will be abstracted below. The rate of multiple gestation pregnancies is 23-30 percent. Current research indicates that washed sperm can live 24-72 hours; however, it does lose potency after 24 hours. Another issue with IUI is that the sperm can keep on swimming beyond the fallopian tube, so the ideal window is really within 6-12 hours of the egg being released, with a larger margin before ovulation than after since the egg's viability is shorter. Sperm can live up to 5 days in fertile mucus, 2-3 days being pretty common, so combining IUI with intercourse may provide better coverage. Losing weight can definitely change your system around. Actually even 10 lbs can do it. The fat cells are where estrogen is stored. Estrogen is a major component when ttc. A slight drop in weight can make a difference. I need to take my own advice and lose some weight. Sometimes when our goal for weigh loss is to "look good" it can be overwhelming. We all want to weigh 120 lbs but in reality that goal can be far fetched. Losing weight for TTC purposes can just be a few lbs and easier to achieve. I think I am going to hit the gym this cycle :) |