Re: Citing your sources
Posted 9/19/2007 1:44:48 PM by Kara


Posted by stickydust


Posted by Kara


Posted by stickydust


Of course, it is always ethical and proper to properly cite any source. However, all ethics aside, there are many circumsstances - everyday vernacular speech as well as this site - for which it would be impractical to do so, and in most of these situations no such requirement would exist.




I disagree that blatantly copying someone's material and posting it on this site without giving credit to the source is an exception to copyright laws.



I agree with you - and while I really didn't read the whole thread to see what specific instances OP was referring to - I would venture to say that most material out there in the internet world is not protected by a copyright. And while I am a little rusty on all this ciopyright stuff (law school was quite a few years age) I do recall from my class in Internet intellectual property that these situations where you are merely quoting from a work with no intent of passing it of as your own are very difficult to win



I agree completely that they are difficult to win, yes, but that doesn't mean that the action doesn't violate copyright laws. (And I even doubt many would ever get sued b/c it is so difficult to prove any damages -- and in many cases, damages may not even exist)

I'm not sure why you think the majority of information contained on the internet isn't covered by copyright laws, though. Copyrights aren't like patents, they don't necessarily need to be registered to be protected (though it's a good idea).

ETA - Copyright infringement only has two basic elements (1) ownership of a copyright by the plaintiff and (2) copying of the copyrighted work by the defendant.

And, most copyright cases are difficult to win. It's a very hard thing to prove. (I'm oversimplifying, too, and I do understand what you're saying! It's extremely unlikely that copying in this fashion would result in liability.)
Print Post      Close Window