Re: Citing your sources
Posted 9/19/2007 1:23:10 PM by Kara


Posted by stickydust

One crucial element of all copyright/intellectual property dicscussion which has been omitted from this discussion is the "fair use doctrine".

All intellectual property claims have exceptions for fair use built into them. Meaning, there are certain uses that are automatically exempt from all copyright infringement. Examples of those would be personal use, educational purposes, and most uses that are not of a commercial purpose or where there is no intent to actually generate money from such use.

Of course, it is always ethical and proper to properly cite any source. However, all ethics aside, there are many circumsstances - everyday vernacular speech as well as this site - for which it would be impractical to do so, and in most of these situations no such requirement would exist.

Of course there are always even exceptions to the exceptions Chat Icon



As an IP attorney, I have to say this is a very general overview of the fair use doctrine and the fair use doctrine is NOT applicable to the circumstances to which the OP was referring.

Posting something on an internet BB is not pesonal use, educational (non-profit educational) use, etc. At the same time, I have never heard that the fair use doctrine covers situations where the alleged infringer does not intend to make a profit. As far as I see it, if the copyright holder can prove damages, it doesn't matter if the alleged infringer intended to make money off of it. I could not post an entire book on the internet (even on a web site that is ad-free) and expect it to be a fair use.

The fair use doctrine generally exists to permit exceptions in certain education-related areas, personal use (meaning I can copy a cd *I* own to a tape for *me only* to play in my car), and to protect permissible parody / satire.

I don't see it's applicability to these sorts of circumstances, though I'd be open to hearing discussion on both sides. The only applicability I do see is that specific damages would be difficult to prove. However, that doesn't mean necessarily impossible.
Print Post      Close Window