Re: What are your thoughts on this?
Posted 9/12/2007 8:25:18 AM by GoldenRod


Posted by ml110


Posted by MissJones

I hope you don't mind me joining this...I'm not a parent, but as a teacher, my only concern would be when does a child learn ways of occupying his or her mind rather than having the constant stimulation of a tv? I mean, as kids, we had to make up silly games to prevent boredom. Kids nowadays have entertainment at their disposal and have not learned that life is not supposed to be exciting 24/7. They are going to school expecting it at every moment. So while I will not judge because I know there are things that I say now I will never do and I'm sure I will do Chat Icon , I just want to express a concern I have about starting up this habit. Chat Icon I mean, there are tvs everywhere...the bank, the supermarket checkout line, airplanes, kitchens, bedrooms, etc. I see the good in them, but at the same time, where is the down time for the brain to just think? When do people read anymore?

Please, no flaming, no 'You're not a mother, so leave,'...I'm just curious.Chat Icon



ITA!! i'm not a parent yet either, but i'm a speech teacher at a school, and i see first hand what having TV, video games, etc is doing to kids. they have no ability to focus or occupy themselves. they expect to have fast-paced entertainment all the time, and can't learn when theres not. i also get concerned about the affect on child's language. the child spends time "zoned out" in front of the TV, and getting no interaction or feedback. the interaction part is so important!
i also agree that our parents did not have DVDs when we were all young, and they were able to "deal" without one. we all learned to behave in restaurants. i know i should never say never, but i just can't see how this would be a good habit to start....



I honestly don't think TV is to blame. DS and DD watch TV, and DS is 4yo, but reading 2nd grade books. We are very interactive with both DC when they watch TV. We have closed captioning on, so DS is reading what the dialog is. He watches educational shows (most of the time... I'm not sure if I would classify Transformers as educational, though... Chat Icon ) I think the problem with TV is when it is used as a babysitter. As long as the parents are involved and interactive with their DC, TV is a useful tool. DS still has a great imagination, makes up very involved and complicated storylines (which I think TV helped with), plays with cars and blocks (again, I think TV gave him a boost with that). He doesn't imitate what he sees on TV, but takes some ideas from there, and expands those ideas (I should probably write some of them down and submit them as ideas for future episodes... Chat Icon ... he "writes" better shows than some that are on the air.... Chat Icon )
Print Post      Close Window