Re: calling all vegetarians and pescatarians.
Posted 9/3/2007 8:22:08 PM by TheLorax

My original conversion to vegetarianism and then veganism was based almost entirely on minimizing the pain my existence caused for other sentient beings.

I definitely agree that crustaceans have been the hardest thing for me to stay away from. I currently eat them (thus am clearly not a vegan/true vegetarian), and most evidence (scientific studies) seem to show that due to their rudimentary nervous system and lack of a 'true' brain, they do not feel pain. I actually find the argument for avoiding eggs, dairy and other products of factory farms more compelling, and try to minimize my dairy/egg intake much more than my shellfish.

Shellfish are actually in the phylum Arthropod, just like spiders and insects. Their nervous system is very similar to insects, so I actually think of eating crustaceans as akin to killing an insect (which, unless we live like Buddhist monks sweeping the ground we are to walk on to remove insects, I am sure we all inadvertently kill everyday).

ETA: Most of the crustacean behavior that may suggest they feel pain (the lobster squirming in the pot, the crabs circling) is actually simply evolutionary adaptation to particular stimuli. A lobster squirms in the hot pot, not because he feels pain, but because it is evolutionarily advantageous for him to escape that environment so he doesn't die and can pass on his genetic code to his offspring. Think of a fiddler crab at the beach that has lost its claw in a battle with another fiddler crab. He doesn't show any type of pain reaction. His gait is not slowed, his ability to forage for food is not hindered, he does not hold up the limb or nurture it in any way to suggest he has experienced pain. The nervous system is simply too primative to convey messages of pain onto the ganglia (brain equivalent) and they are too primative to process any such messages.
Print Post      Close Window