Re: calling all vegetarians and pescatarians.
Posted 9/3/2007 9:51:25 AM by SummerMom


Posted by Jesaroo

i'm not asking you guys what to call myself.i mean, how do you feel about eating shellfish, meaning, do you?

....

i hate eating shellfish and i hated eating fish BUTTTTTTTTT they are in my mind no comparison to land animals. fish only have a 10 second memory. and shellfish have no central nervous system.
they arent raised in cages in their own feces, branded, chained up, beat, neglected, murdered inhumaly etc for teh most part. its the whole way certain animals are raised that kill me.
(obviously boiling a lobster isnt humane) but overall i think you catch my drift. *NOT saying i am ok with them being killed for food or that they dont ahve feelings. i wouldnt be giving it up if i felt that way, i just mean its very different than say a cow or chicken.

i will give them up as well, sooner than later, but it is a first step giving up fish only a few days ago.

Liza, how long have you been vegan? everyone i know who was vegan went back due to poor health.



You have to do what is right for you. There is no "right" or "wrong" way to eat; you have to figure out what you're comfortable with.

But you specifically asked about shellfish. It sounds to me like you're making excuses. Don't get me wrong, that's FINE - again, I don't judge and it's not my right to tell you how to eat. But I just think that if you say, "I don't eat animals because it's wrong... except for shellfish because they're different" it's like, "It's wrong to eat animals... except for turkeys because they're ugly." You know? Eat shellfish if you want. But be honest with yourself that you're eating it for the protein or for the taste and not because some living things are more alive than others.

(For the record: I stopped eating meat 9 years ago, but kept eating shellfish for about 6 months after that. Then I watched an episode of Iron Chef where the secret ingredient was Lobster. One of the chefs took a lobster out of the tank - alive - and chopped it in half. The front half crawled one way, and the back half crawled the other. I was like, "hey - any creature that can do that... I'm not eating it!" And from then on I was a "real" vegetarian.)
Print Post      Close Window