Re: Top Chef?---UPDATED WITH SPOILER
Posted 8/23/2007 12:00:41 AM by wp


Posted by DandN

I could be wrong - but has Casey EVER made something that the judges really really liked?

the latin dish - chicken in coffee molases sauce - they hated it.

the dish she made when she was on Joey and Howie's team? they hated it but she had won the quickfire and couldnt be eliminated.

tonight's episode - the monkfish - they didnt like it.

And TRE goes home? I just dont see why she is still there!



That is exactly what I mean and totally agree with you. If this challenge was based on past performances, then casey would have gone home NOT tre.
I felt the same way when Casey didnt go home during the latin challenge and the other chef Lia (?) went home....they didnt use past performances to make the decision but they have given Howie multiple chances---for example in the beginning when he didn't even complete his dish---he only got the risotto out and not the frog legs!!!!!!
Print Post      Close Window