Re: Does anyone know how the Graco Safeseat compares to the Snugride as far as safety is concerned??
Posted 8/7/2007 8:46:54 AM by Dragonfly75


Posted by Summerrluvv


Posted by DancinBarefoot


Posted by MrsDiamondgrlie

Actually I forgot where I read it but that Consumer Reports thing that came out was recalled.

ETA: Here it is: CNN link



I read that, but think about it, on Long Island the speed limit might be 55 MPH, but if you actually try going that slow you'll get run off the road. To keep up with the lunatics on the road you have to drive over 65 MPH - and Consumer Reports tested the car seats at that kind of high speed and only two passed the test (even if they did mistakenly say the test was done at 35 MPH).

Frankly, since someone actually tested the car seats at high speeds, I'll stick with the one that passed - the Snugride, over the Safeseat any day.



I agree! Does ANYONE drive 35mph these days? Most places the speed limit is 45-55, in MI it's 70 on the highways, so I don't know why they would crash test them only at 35mph. I'm glad Consumer Reports did it at 65.



This is not actually accurate -- the speed of the car was not 65mph -- that's the speed that the car was projected to after the crash -- a crash like that no one would survive. The Snugride was not tested the same way, that's why it passed and none of the others did. No car seat would have passed this test the way it was set up. Do a google search on Consumer Reports corrections.

I read a lot about it because I have the SafeSeat and was concerned. Unfortunately, the correction has never been clarified publically and a lot of people still have false impressions about the car seats. From the research I have done, the Graco SafeSeat and Chicco KeyFit are the favorites of Car Seat Techs because they are easy to install and do well in crashes.
Print Post      Close Window