Re: "thats not really NY"
Posted 7/2/2007 7:57:29 PM by Jesaroo


Posted by leighla


Posted by Jesaroo


Posted by Emily

Well, I am from Ohio and been here 7 years....

I pay NY taxes..so that makes me a new yorker. So deal with it.

eta: I have a NY License, too. Look it says I am from NY...Chat Icon



beinf "from" new york and being a "new yorker" are different. no one is denying youre a new yorker.

you are FROM Ohio, but LIVE in NY. you are a New Yorker, but not FROM New York.



So when someone asks me where I'm FROM should I say Philadelphia, since I was born there, but only lived there until I was 6?

Or Delaware, since I was raised there?

Or State College, since I lived there for 4 years?

Or Long Island since I lived there for five years?

Or NJ since I live here now?

Chat Icon



i think where you were raised is where you are from.

like i was born in one town , but i grew up in another and then moved on form there. but i always say hte town i'm "from" is teh one i grew up in.


eta: for example, i have lived in Brooklyn for 5 years now, but i dont say i am "from" brooklyn. i say i'm from hauppage, long island
Print Post      Close Window