Re: Do you feel American Idol is a...
Posted 5/22/2007 2:06:29 PM by Superkat


Posted by LaurenExp


Posted by Superkat


Posted by LaurenExp

Total popularity contest. If it wasn't, Melinda would be the winner, IMO.




Melinda can sing, without a doubt. But it is very difficult to market her. What genre would she sing? Can you sell her as a star? Can you put her with Christina, Brittany, Mariah, J LO, Avril? It isn't enough to be an amazing singer. You also have to be marketable in today's musical environment. In my opinion, that is why both she and Lakisha didn't make it to the final 2.



I agree, Melinda is hard to market. But so was Ruben...and I think Fantasia was pretty hard to market, too. But I think they have their place. In may not be in the teeny-bopper circuit, it may be with the 30 and 40-somethings, but as Simon always says...this is a singing competition, and I just think that's what it should be about. I'm not trying to sound like a "purist" or anything, I just think the best singer should win.



I see your point but realistically, how well did Ruben or Fantasia's CD's sell? Ruben's CD was a disaster, it sold way under expectations. Similar story with Fantasia. Winning AI doesn't MAKE you successful, it just guarantees that you will have a CD released.

Here is a rough break down of CD sales by past AI finalists. As of March 2007.

Kelly Clarkson
8.14 Million

Carrie Underwood
4.81 Million

Clay Aiken
4.53 Million

Ruben Studdard
2.41 Million

Fantasia Barrino
1.95 Million

Print Post      Close Window