Re: Amercian Idol 4/17
Posted 4/18/2007 7:39:22 AM by MsMBV


Posted by heidla

I was a little behind.

Phil- sounded good. I like his voice and I felt like this week he finally performed the song with some personality.

Jordin- I thought she sounded great. A little shakey when she first went into the chorus, but I can forgive that it happens to the best sometimes. I also thought she gave a very mature performance.

Lakisha- I thought she really connected to the lyric of the song. She did push through the chorus a little hard at first, but other then that I thought she sounded good.

Sanjaya- There are no words. I have heard soooooo many people sing that song and that was honeatly one of the worst renditions I have ever heard. I also think that this "fame" is going to his head. Time to go!!!!!

Chris- He was okay. A few clunky notes and he seemed lost in his performance.

Melinda- I thought for once she looked like she had a neck!!! She sounded great .

Blake- I thought he was kinda bad this week. I think that he was born in the wrong decade. He always reminds me of those 80's British bands.

ITA with most of this. I however did not care for LaKeisha at all. Her lisp (although I am not making fun) is becoming a hindering factor in being able to listen to her....maybe it was just the song but it was very noticeable this week.

I loved Jordin & Phil...but Phil should have worn a hat.

Sanjaya is just ridiculous, and really Seacrest, STFU while Simon is critiquing....that was ssssooooooo annyoingChat Icon
Print Post      Close Window