proposed smoking ban
Posted 4/4/2007 4:16:24 PM by dpli

I am no fan of smoking, but I think this (making parks smoke free) is a little over the top. Thoughts?

April 3, 2007, 9:51 PM EDT

Nassau County Executive Thomas Suozzi launched a new front in his war on smoking Tuesday, announcing that the county is considering a smoking ban in parks.

At a news conference to tout a proposed $2 per pack regional cigarette tax, Suozzi said the county's health department will investigate making the parks smoke-free.

"It's something we're thinking about," he said of the parks ban. "I'd like to do it."

The cigarette tax hike Suozzi is seeking, which needs state legislative approval, has support in the Assembly, but may stall in the Republican-controlled Senate. However, a smoke-free park initiative requires only local legislative approval and has already won support from Presiding Officer Judy Jacobs (D-Woodbury), who said banning smoking in the parks would be consistent with the county's other smoking cessation efforts.

"Parks are synonymous with nature and health, and certainly smoking doesn't fit under that at all," said Jacobs, whose husband, Sidney, was a smoker and died of lung cancer in 2004.

Several California cities, including San Francisco, have enacted smoking bans in public parks and on golf courses. Belmont, a San Jose suburb, may ban smoking citywide excluding only the interiors of single-family homes.

Mary Curtis, Suozzi's deputy county executive for health and human services, said banning smoking in parks is still an idea, not a formal proposal.

Suffolk County Executive Steve Levy has never considered banning smoking in parks, said Levy spokesman Ed Dumas, who said the issue hadn't come up. Suffolk Presiding Officer William Lindsay (D-Holbrook) would not support a parks smoking ban, spokeswoman Kara Hahn said.

Not surprisingly, making parks smoke-free elicited strong opinions from smokers and smoking-rights activists. Audrey Silk, a retired New York City police officer who founded Citizens Lobbying Against Smoker Harassment, said banning smoking outdoors has no discernable benefit.

"Show me a study about harm outdoors," she said. "It's social engineering, it's stigmatizing a group of people."

Ryan Schoenfeld, a 23-year-old SUNY-Old Westbury student from Uniondale, said the outdoors is the only place left to smoke.

"I think it's all right to be able to smoke outside," he said. "We're already not allowed to smoke inside."

With the park smoking ban still being researched, Nassau's odds of winning state approval for a $2 per pack cigarette tax appeared long Tuesday, as influential Republicans in the state Senate either backed away from the proposal or rejected it altogether. Also, county officials in Suffolk, Westchester and Rensselear Counties have expressed skepticism about enacting a cigarette tax.

Sen. Kemp Hannon (R-Garden City), the chairman of the Senate Health Committee, said he will not introduce the bill and is opposed to any new taxes. Spokesmen for Sen. Charles Fuschillo (R-Merrick) and Majority Leader Joe Bruno (R-Brunswick) said they have no plans to be part of a cigarette tax increase.

Sen. Dean Skelos (R-Rockville Centre), the deputy majority leader, could not be reached.

Hannon said Nassau can find ways to curtail smoking other than taxes. He said he'd raise the minimum smoking age to 21 and do a better job collecting taxes from cigarettes bought online or at Indian reservations.

"I'm not high on raising taxes at all," Hannon said.

New York's state legislators typically allow local governments to raise their own sales taxes, said Frank Mauro, the executive director of the Fiscal Policy Institute in Albany. But without a Nassau sponsor in the Senate, raising the cigarette tax will be a hard sell, he said.

"If the Long Island senators are opposing it and Nassau most wants it, you'd think it might not be done as simply as the local sales tax increases are," he said.

Jacobs said that she will look elsewhere for a Senate sponsor if the Nassau delegation declines to introduce the bill.

"It would be nice to have them, and we'd like them to show that they have an interest in Nassau County," she said.

Staff writer Carl MacGowan contributed to this report.
Copyright 2007 Newsday Inc.

Print Post      Close Window