Re: American Idol- 3/20
Posted 3/20/2007 9:10:18 PM by Goldi0218
Posted by leighla
Posted by Goldi0218
Posted by leighla
Posted by Goldi0218
Posted by june262004
Lakisha is my favorite but
See that is going to be a problem. People will vote for favorites, not who was the best tonight. At least the teens will.
I don't think people should vote on the week, I think they should vote on overall performance.
I disagree.
ETA: The performances from weeks before have already been evaluated as that is why they are there now.
Yeah, but let's say it's a bad genre for that person and they've done well the rest of the time.
Do you penalize them for the producer's choice of genre?
This is a contest. They need to be versatile. If it were American R and B Idol, then they would only sing R and B. If it were Country Idol, they would have to sing only country. Its what the producers expect. IMO.
|