Re: american idol
Posted 3/9/2007 4:43:10 PM by mka06


Posted by MrsF519


Posted by mka06

Antonella deserved to go... Honestly - Sabrina is better than Haley - but I actually cast a vote for Haley. Why? Because I felt bad for her. The way the convo went after her performance I think was unnecessarily mean. Plus, she is better than Antonella and a number of the men that are still there.

I was more bummed to see Sundance go then Sabrina... He was one of the best guys and there are still a lot of great girls left.



Chat Icon You proved my pointChat Icon
This isn't about making people "feel" good. Because of votes like that, my friend was sent homeChat Icon
The show has been on long enough for the contestants to know that they have to be able to take critisism. They all go in there knowing what to expect. Just like I am sure Sabrina knew that there was a chance she would get sent home for some BS like a sympathy vote. Its the nature of the competition and it sucks!

Just giving my honest opinion.



Sorry that your firiend got sent home. I'm sure that sucks for you and I'm sure if I were in your shoes with a personal connection to a contestant, I would feel the same way.

THere are lots of things I hate about American Idol --

-- that the "tryouts" with the judges are totally controlled by the producers to have the best and the worst appear on tv..

- that the judges are not consistent in their advice

- that the judges bicker (i watch to hear the singing, not them argue with each other)

- that ryan asks questions of the judges that perpetuates whatever they are bickering about

- and finally - when the judges are rude.

I agree that it is a singing competition and that nobody up there should be made to feel good just for the sake of it. That being said -- there are ways to say you didn't do a good job and critique people without being rude, esp when you consider that these are the JUDGES that picked these people to go to Hollywood. If she was so bad as to deserve the rudeness they dished, why didn't they cut her along time ago?

That's why I voted for her the other night... and I have only voted on one other occassion ever in the years that I've watched AI. I don't participate in fan clubs, web sites, etc... and I probably won't vote again in this competition...

I also think this show has been around enough yrs where this has happened, that the judges should be aware of this factor and have control over it by controlling how they speak to the contestants... (again - constructive criticism is possible)

Anyway, I realize that I may still have proved your point, but I just thought I'd explain my opinion on the show...
Print Post      Close Window