|
Re: american idol
Posted 3/8/2007 9:37:44 PM by MrsERod thought you guys might find this an interesting read...(I know I sure did) this is just PART of an excerpt written by Amrita Rajan - a writer based in NYC If Sanjaya Malakar was Indian, then he'd be performing live on Indian Idol, getting sneered at by the likes of Cowell-wannabe (I understand every Idol country's got one) Palash Sen, rather than getting ripped into shreds by Cowell himself. But he's not Indian, he's American. So he gets to stand in front of His Britishness and learn just how much he sucks. To the credit of the Americans, they get it. Well, it's hard not to get it when the name of the bloody show is American Idol isn't it? If they love him, then it's because he's a baby and we've already seen last year with the agonizing success of Chicken Little (sorry, can't remember his name) that America loves its loser babies. By the same token, if they hate him it's because he practically handed us all a photo of himself to be used as the definition of "suck". Now, I don't know the Malakars personally, and I don't know if it bothers them when people call them Indians or whether they are proud to be called Indian and frankly, I don't care. People have to deal with their own stuff all the time and figuring out who you are is an essential part of the journey into adulthood. I wish them luck and am not inclined to pry unless Shyamali turns into Britney Spears or something (dude, Shyamali, I know you're young and probably mad as hell right now but please don't, okay?). What bothers me is that people expect me to give a crap about Sanjaya because of his ethnicity. I've had some severe doubts about the talent on the show this year and when I look at some of the people who got into the final 24, I still can't help but think that I'd as soon cut my throat as buy albums put out by some of these people. Well, okay that's hyperbole - if buying a sucky CD with Sundance Head yelling his head off can save my life, obviously I'll do it, but that's not the point. The point is, I don't want to vote for Sanjaya. I think he's a sweet kid but he's completely outclassed by his peers in this competition at this point in time (seriously, they need to set the age limit a little higher - it's a massacre out there on stage every year) and I am not going to vote for him based on who his father was. It's racist, it's condescending, and at a time when music lovers everywhere are bemoaning the industry's rapid collapse into the bottomless pit of mediocrity combined with commercialism (Paris Hilton has a single out - Paris f*cking Hilton people!), it's about the worst message to send record companies. I didn't buy Norah Jones' album because her father was Pt. Ravi Shankar; I bought it because she blew my mind. So I'm not going to vote for Sanjaya Malakar's boring pipes when Melinda Doolittle breaks my heart every time she lights up the stage. And I'm not less of an Indian for saying so. |