Re: Whose bed is it anyway?
Posted 3/3/2007 10:39:18 PM by monkeybride


Posted by Maathy317


Posted by Dragonfly75


Posted by monkeybride




This poster is, absolutely, right. I just don't get the benefit to the child of co-sleeping. I can see the benefit to the parent. What is the point of re-training them everytime they need to be in a different sleep situation? Some children go from the parents' bed, to the bassinette and then to the crib. Each time makes it harder on the child. They scream and cry because they can't understand what is going on. Wouldn't it just be easier on them if they were put in their crib from the very beginning? If you need to hear what is going on in their room, that's what baby monitors are for. It seems to me this would eliminate all problems involving sleeping. I understand that in some situations a separate room may not be available. I guess it's "different strokes for different folks" and I come from a different generation than any of you. I just don't see the point.




OK first-Co Sleeping does not have to mean having the child in your bed. In Attachment Parenting terms (where this whole idea comes from) it is having the child in bed with you or in your room. The reason behind cosleeping and the benefit is so that you can be immediately attentive to you child's needs. If they are in your room you hear them sooner, get to them sooner etc. Obviously the majority of cosleeping parents don't believe in letting children CIO.
I personally could not imagine having my newborn daughter who was tight in my belly for 9 months sleep in the giant room and a giant crib all by herself with no familiar noises, surroundings or smells. To me it almost seemed cruel. Co sleeping really wasn't a benefit to me because I didn't sleep well at all. Eventually we moved DD into a cradle in our room next to the bed but still she was with us and could hear and smell us. IMO I think babies can feel afraid, left alone and scared. Some may disagree but so be it.
When DD was old enough and none of us were getting sleep we transitioned her to her crib with very little hassle. We did the same routine, she just went down in a different spot.
Honestly I really don't know why there is so much controversy over this. It's just like BFing. Either co sleep or don't. It's your perogative.
I really don't see cosleeping leading to behavioral issues. If I child has issues it's for reasons far beyond cosleeping.
I slept with my mom for a long time and I was super disciplined.
I can play the other side and say that my daughter is more secure and well behaved because she coslept and always felt attached to us and always had her needs met and didn't CIO.



Have to say I completely agree. Thanks for taking the time to write that out. Chat Icon


Let me start by saying that I don't completely agree with the behavioral issues theory. I think you are right in that these issues don't stem just from co-sleeping. You state the whole idea of co-sleeping is so that you can be immediately attentive to your child's needs. So, if your child is in a room directly across the hall from you, as mine was, you couldn't immediately take care of their needs when they cried? You state that you thought it was cruel to leave your child in a room, in a big crib by herself. Isn't it more cruel to keep making children change their sleep patterns and sleeping habits? Isn't it more cruel to listen to them cry and scream for what seems like hours because they can't understand why, at this particular point in time, they can't be with mom and dad any longer? Isn't it more cruel to do this over and over again. It seems to me all this can be avoided. Yes, it's true that no one will have a teenager sleeping with them, but, just stop and think a minute how hard it was for them to adjust and what they went through.

You were lucky. Your child adapted very easily. Unfortunately, that is not true for the majority. It's akin to running a race and, just when you see the finish line, someone moves it. When you're at work and you've been working on a project for an extended length of time and you're almost done, it becomes frustrating when someone decides to change it and you have to start all over. Don't you just want to scream? We're adults and we sometimes have a hard time adjusting to change even with all the practice we've had in our lives. Just think how it is for the little ones who have had no practice whatsoever and are just trying to keep up. As I said earlier, I just don't see the logic in it.



You're right we were lucky that DD adapted well but if I had to do it over again and had a child that didn't adapt I would assume that my child wasn't ready to be in a big room and bed by themselves and I would let them continue to cosleep in my room. If it wasn't working in our bed then I would get them a bed in our room. If that didn't work then I guess I would do my best to make an easy transition to their own room that didn't involve tears and stress to my child.

I honestly don't think we should be comparing children to adults. I think that's part of the problem. People have these helpless babies and put huge expectations on them from the time they are born. "When will my baby sleep through the night?" "When can my baby have solids?" "Why doesn't my baby have teeth yet?" "How soon can I stop nursing", etc. IMO children have needs to be met and they are only small and vulnerable once and I feel it is my responsibility to make my child as comfortable and secure as possible. IMO that doesn't mean making them do something before they are ready to.
I mean why don't people have huge debates over people not forcing away the pacifier, bottle or diapers? None of which I would force my daughter to do either because I would think when the time was right she would give them up on her own and no end up going to school in diapers or drinking a bottle.

Again all of this is JMO and I follow the principles of Attachment Parenting so I realize most people won't agree with my ideals and that's OK. I am happy with how my daughter is turning out and how DH and I are able to relate to her so what we do is working for us, to each his own.
Print Post      Close Window