Re: WARNING: Touchy subject inside...
Posted 3/1/2007 7:55:44 PM by BlondeJD


Posted by Janice

can I ask an honest to God question?

If this guy was on trial for murder, how come DUI's aren't called attempted murder? Does anyone know the legal reasoning for it?

The whole case makes me ill. To think what that family has gone throughChat Icon




If a person is charged with murder in connection with a DUI, they're generally charged with vehicular manslaughter because there isn't an *intent* to cause death - it's considered an act of negligence or recklessness. Because the crime of murder requires the intent to cause death, the crime of attempted murder also requires that same intent. This is the reason that there's not a crime of attempted manslaughter for example - because the crime is not one of intent, but one of negligence or recklessness. Hope this helps Chat Icon

Personally, I think 18 years is an adequate sentence but I would have been even happier if he'd received a harsher sentence.
Print Post      Close Window