Re: WARNING: Touchy subject inside...
Posted 3/1/2007 2:47:17 PM by MrsS2005
Posted by MsMBV
Posted by MrsS2005
Posted by Janice
can I ask an honest to God question?
If this guy was on trial for murder, how come DUI's aren't called attempted murder? Does anyone know the legal reasoning for it?
The whole case makes me ill. To think what that family has gone through
It's extremely rare for drunk drivers to be charged (and convicted) of murder. To be guilty of murder, one must have mens rea (a guilty mind). Basically, there must be some type of intent to harm/kill someone, or the person must act with reckless disregard for human life. People who are drunk are typically considered to have a diminished capacity, and do not meet the level of "guilty mind" required for murder (the same is true for those with mental illness). From a legal standpoint, this was definitely a controversial case. As horrible as his actions were, I'm not sure they rose to the legal definition of murder.
The real problem is that the setencing guidelines for drunk driving, especially when it results in injury or death, are too light. Instead of arguing of whether this man and other drunk drivers should be charged with murder, the states should enact harsher penalties for drunk driving.
ITA, but in order to have harsher sentencing doesn't: a) a precedent have to be set (which I think this would qualify b) a perception of it being a more heinous act?
And I am asking this in earnest, b/c I cannot figure for the life of me how it is already not this way.
I'm not quite sure how sentencing guidelines are set. I believe each state has its own sentencing guidelines commission, but I'm not sure whether the commission is part of the legislature or judiciary. Courts can overturn the guidelines for being unconstitutional, but that's usually if the guidelines are too harsh, not too lenient.
With sentencing guidelines, a precedent doesn't need to be set to change them. Again, I'm not sure whether the legislature or the judiciary has the power to revise them. I think cases like this may help encourage changes and may persuade the legislature to act.
|